Have you ever wondered why Pocatello Avenue, leading from Yellowstone to Clark Street, is so odd and doesn’t seem to fit into the rest of the city? Thanks to insurance companies we can find the answer. Yes, insurance documents can be pretty dry reading. However, insurance companies keep detailed records of massive amounts of information that can be a treasure trove for solving tricky history questions. In the late 18th century they began keeping incredibly detailed maps that were used for assessing fire risks. One of the best known mapping companies in the United States was Sanborn and in 1907 the Sanborn company published a map of downtown Pocatello. Here are detailed portions of their maps of the city with some amazing history lessons for local historians.
The first map shows central downtown on Center Street west of the tracks. Nearly every building is labeled by what it’s used for along with the address numbers (colors indicate the type of building, look for the key in one of the last photos). You’ll note that the Bannock Hotel on Center and Arthur is shown including a rudimentary floor plan.
The second image is on the other side of the tracks between East Center and Bonneville. The Auditorium Opera House is at the top, but you also might note the buildings marked “Rest (Chine)” which are not seen on the west side of the tracks. Once you see “Chine Laundry” it all makes sense. These are the Chinese restaurants and laundry.
The next image shows Pocatello Avenue, but not on the east side of the tracks where we see it today, but crossing diagonally through Main, joining Benton Street, and then crossing Arthur. Why Pocatello Avenue dead ends in an alley is anyone’s guess, but the fact the houses to the east of the alley are railroad housing gives us a clue.
The fourth image again takes us to the other side of the tracks where we are used to seeing Pocatello Avenue today as we take it as a shortcut to get to the Center Street underpass. Two more Chinese restaurants and another Chinese laundry are shown as well as a building marked “Colored Men’s Club Rooms”. Clearly the railroad tracks were the dividing line between the majority and minorities of the city with the Triangle Neighborhood being the home of Pocatello's minorities and their businesses. There was also a lot more money on the west side of the tracks, but between East Center and East Clark on 2nd Ave there is a log building with a dirt roof.
The last map detail shows the exact position of the railroad workshop buildings due east of West Sublette. This map also gives us a hint of why Pocatello Avenue is so skewed to the rest of the city. The original Utah Northern line came through the valley where ISU stands today and then headed north to Blackfoot and on to Montana. However, when the Oregon Short Line came into the area it headed Northwest to go around the mountains so it could turn West and go past Michaud. Pocatello Avenue follows the Utah Northern realignment labeled here “Oregon Short Line (Butte Branch)”. That is why Pocatello Avenue on the east side of the tracks is so odd - it predated the city and followed the railroad, not the grid of the city.
But why in the world is there a Pocatello Avenue shown on the west side of the tracks on the map slashing a line generally in the same direction through the block between Whitman and Benton and Main and Arthur? After all, the railroad came straight into the valley from the southeast aimed to head out to the northwest. There was no need on the west side of the tracks to follow the spur that diverted from the main line off toward Butte, Montana. And why is Pocatello Avenue on the west side of the tracks so much wider than the other streets? What gives?
The answer comes by recalling that Pocatello was built as a railroad town. Remember those railroad housing buildings? The fact they were built by the railroad indicates that the railroad built them on the railroad’s right of way. A little looking at later maps shows that Pocatello Avenue on the west side of the tracks is a separate railroad right of way that extends from the area of the yard southwest toward City Creek. Underneath that right of way is a 6” water pipe that delivered the water to the yard (part of the original agreement with the Shoshone and Bannock). Since water was one of the first things the station at Pocatello would need, the waterline was brought directly to the station and remained separate from the municipal supply. Once established, the railroad would nto allow anyone but themselves to build much on the right of way since it could break the pipe or compromise the railroad’s ability to repair or replace it. It would also violate the agreement they had with the Sho-Ban Tribes. Thus Pocatello Avenue (almost certainly one of the first pieces of construction in the city) was born running diagonally to the tracks, not so much because the town wanted a road there, but because the railroad didn’t want anything else there! Moreover it was wider than other streets because it was defined by the railroad’s easement and not normal city needs like the rest of the streets.
As time went on the railroad gradually allowed more building on the right of way. Today Pocatello Avenue west of the tracks is all but disappeared except for the “shadow” of a few oddly placed buildings that still delineate the old railroad easement.
The final detail (other than the map legend) is something the insurance companies were keen to know about - in case of fire, could it be put out? So, a detailed description of the city’s water system and fire department are given. We learn that the city’s water came from Mink Creek and Gibson Jack creek (City Creek was only used by the railroad as part of the original act of Congress based on the agreement with the Fort Hall Tribes for an easement). We also find out only the fire chief and the wagon driver were paid members of the 30-man fire department. Finally, it tells us how the fire alarm was sounded.